Click to edit Master text styles
Second level
Third level
Fourth level
Fifth level
Introduction
The
purpose of this presentation is to develop a systematic method for writing a
DBQ. Although methods of determining the content of specific
documents may vary, the organizational structure should be
helpful in allowing students to approach the assignment with
an increased measure of confidence. In addition to the primary objective of performance
on the national exam, the process described herein also illustrates effective methods
for researching and developing any written project, especially term papers.
Note:
* denotes slide change.
Preparation
Students
should have the handouts that include a sample DBQ instruction page, the
prompt, and the documents to be used. This presentation will focus
on question #1 from the book DBQ Practice: AP World
History.
Dialog
The
AP World History exam contains three different types of essays: a COMPARE AND CONTRAST
essay, a CHANGE OVER TIME essay, and a DOCUMENT-BASED QUESTION.
For
the next few days, we will focus on the last form of essay, which is commonly
referred to as a DBQ. A DBQ requires analysis of primary
sources.
Let’s
look at the sample material provided. We will use a step-by-step method to
analyze both the question and the documents provided.
Our first step will be to analyze the
question or prompt. It is extremely important that we understand
what the question requires, so let’s see how we can break it down into its
basic parts.
Are
there any terms or words that you don’t understand?
What
is the question asking for?*
Can
anything be eliminated?*
We
will have to determine what patterns are apparent.* We also need to find
“cultural consequences” or influences on the cultures of each
participant.*
We
know what the question is asking for and we will need to organize our
response, but before we do that let’s make sure we’ve utilized all of the
information provided.
DBQs
often provide a historical background and that information should be
used.*
There’s
some important information here…*
There
could be a possible region grouping…*
*just
don’t lose an opportunity to use the material.
This
is where we will end today. Please review the material tonight so that when we
begin our discussion you will have a basic understanding of what
the documents discuss. Some of them might be difficult, but don’t
worry if you don’t fully understand them—just try to get a general
idea of trade and its impact on civilizations.
We will now discuss Step 2 in the
process: organizing the information in the documents.
Note to teacher: Begin by addressing
any questions about the documents students reviewed as
homework.
In
order to analyze and organize the documents, it can be helpful to develop a
table or a chart. Some things will be the same for every DBQ. They
are:
*document
number
*major
point of the document
*point
of view
*information
needed
These
are usually the general instructions before the actual prompt or question.*
Preparation
You
may have students develop a table in their notebook, or you can use the blank
table that appears as a handout at the end of the Teacher’s Guide.
Dialog
Here
is what an organizational table might look like.*
The
“universals” are document number, needed information, point of view, and the
major concept or important point from the document.*
Now
let’s look at possible ways to group the documents based upon the information
in each.
*One
method of grouping these documents would be to identify “who’s talking” and
what region they’re discussing. For example, the first document
is a European describing Africa; the second document is a European
discussing the New World; and other documents have a European
discussing Europe, a Muslim discussing Africa, Europeans discussing China, a European
discussing the Mongols, and three maps.
Preparation
Note
that some of the entries on the slides will be very short. Students should be
advised to abbreviate, but to make sure that they still put in enough
information to use for writing the essay.
Each
of the “fill-ins” will reflect analysis of the documents. Individual
interpretations may vary, but the process of analysis
should follow the same pattern.
Dialog
Step
3 is to read the documents and to figure out how they fit into our table.*
Here is our table. We’ll look at each
document and determine the categories to be checked as
we read. Notice that as we complete the table, some items only require a check
while others require longer responses. Some of the responses you
will see on the slide are very short because of limited space. Your
responses should include enough information so that you
don’t have to go back to the document.
Here
are the categories:
•Begin with the
“universals”*
•Put down the “who
and where”*
•Determine “pattern”
and “consequence”*
Now we will organize the
information from each of the documents. First the easy stuff: Number, and then location from either
the info on the source or (if necessary) from the narrative. When reading the document,
always keep in mind that you should look for information that relates to the columns (i.e., regions,
“pattern,” and “consequence”). Remember,
don’t try to summarize the whole document—take a “just the facts” approach instead. When you have filled in the
information for a document, draw a line across and start the next document.
Here
is the first document. Note that the sections in red relate to the information
we need to answer the
prompt. (Note to teacher: Take some time to discuss the sections in red.)
Here is the “assessment” for the
chart: Check box “A” for Africa, and indicate as briefly as possible the main points that refer to
the prompt (for example, women use the veiling process, the visiting merchants settle and marry into
prominent African families). A possible
point of view would center on an outsider’s assessment or perception of what
is happening; it might
therefore be a little “ethnocentric” in its evaluation.
Now let’s fill in the
information.
Document #1:
•The region is “A.”
•The major concept that relates to the prompt is Muslims’
effect on African cultures (veiling and
intermarriage).
•The document relates to a specific “consequence.”
•There is a particular point of view—an outsider judging
what he sees based upon his own cultural
bias.
•
Keep in mind that this is your
diagram, so put only as much info as you need to help recall specific points about the document. The
idea is that when you begin to write you will not have to go back to the document—just the
chart.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Most
charts and maps present patterns or connections of some type. They very seldom
reflect a point of view
unless they exaggerate physical sizes or some other aspect. Note how this map shows a pattern of extensive
contacts between northern Africa (which was predominantly Muslim during this period) and sub-Saharan
Africa.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
We
are now getting a sense that all of the documents are from Europeans and
Muslims describing cultural
contacts from their point of view—but where are the comments and perceptions of the Africans, Asians,
Mongols, and Aztecs? It would be interesting to see how their perceptions compare with those
of the “outsiders.”
Walk
the class through interpretation of this document. Make sure to give students
an opportunity to complete
the table before revealing the answers.
Walk
the class through how to fill in the table; don’t forget to give students an
opportunity to figure out
the answers on their own before revealing them.
Now let’s see how we can
begin to group our documents for the essay:
•Documents can be grouped according to specific objectives
of the prompt
•They can also be grouped by patterns, consequences, or by
the theme of “forced change” (which
contrasts with changes that followed a natural process)
•In addition, they can be grouped by regions
Now let’s see how the
documents can fit together to form the body of your essay:
•The first group of documents involves European and Muslim
impressions of Africa
•The next group is related to China
•The last group documents focuses on conversions and
relocations as “consequences” of trade
These groupings provide you with the
content for three paragraphs that can form the body of your essay. Your next step is to form
a topic sentence based on the categories of the groupings and to explain why each of the documents in the
grouping is relevant. After this, all
that’s left is to compose your thesis (opening) paragraph and your concluding
paragraph.
The
last step is to develop a thesis, address the need for additional documents to
allow for a better
assessment of the prompt, and then review the process we have completed.
Let’s
look at what kind of information might help us get a better “picture.” Is
there a bias that needs to
be balanced? Is there something that would make the assessment more accurate?
As we discussed earlier, all of
the documents for this DBQ come from Europeans and Muslims describing trade contacts from
their point of view. Where are the comments and perceptions of Africans, Asians, Mongols, and Aztecs? It
would be interesting to see how their
perceptions compare with those of the “outsiders.” Missing information can
often provide the source
for an effective conclusion.
Note to teacher: Keep in mind that
students may develop other interpretations and theses which should be encouraged and analyzed
by the class as a whole.
The
last and most difficult step of any writing process is the thesis. Can you
find a pattern, a rationale
or concept, or a question or dilemma? Is there something else that strikes you
after reading the
documents? Was there a group that seemed to have a biased approach to the topic? Any thesis that requires you to
use the documents to support your position can be an effective.
Remember,
on the AP World History exam, the thesis must be derived from the documents
and the documents must be used to support the thesis.
In this case, the documents give
an impression that Muslim contacts had more of an impact on the regions they visited than the
Europeans did. The Europeans were either trying to adapt and just survive, standing in awe
of what they saw, or they were more interested in converting their contacts. Using the
historical background, it does make sense because Muslim societies were at a higher point
during this time period while the Europeans were in the so-called “Dark Ages.”
You have now developed a thesis
for your first paragraph, while the previous slide shows a conclusion you might use for the last
paragraph of your essay.
Let’s
review the process. (Note to teacher: Click through each of the steps and read
them to the class.)
Remember, the more we practice
this process the easier it will be to focus on the important parts of the documents. It will help
make your essays meaningful, effective, and enjoyable to read. This process can also be used
for developing effective term papers. The major difference is with term papers is that someone will present
you with a topic, rather than you coming
up with a topic or thesis on your own and then going to look for documents to support it. Think of each reference for
a term paper as a document that can be analyzed using the same methods we discussed in this presentation.
Organizing the sources for your term
paper in a chart can make it easier to separate the information you have
gathered from your research
into its component parts: thesis, body of factual information, and
conclusion.